The Official PokéMarioDex Discussion Thread!

[EpicGyllynn]

Okay guys, in keeping with Pokemon Tradition, we need 3 Starter Pokemario's! Obviously Koopa and Goomba are there, but who should the 3rd be?

[Koopalmier]

*points at the second post on this topic*

[Le Mario Bro]

...Maybe my choices could end up being Second Gen starters?

@ Gylls:

Bullet Bill Blaster (Steel)
Evolves at Lv. 10
Bombshell Bill Blaster (Steel)
Evolves at Lv. 25
Bonzai Bill Blaster (Steel)

[EpicGyllynn]

...Why have them be Blasters? Why not just Bills? Oh well, it works. Why not have them as 1st Generation Starters, though? ShyGuys shouldn't be Starters as they have no direct lineage like a Koopa or Goomba. See, a starter must Evolve twice w/ NO requirements but Lv. Koopa Troopa, Goomba, and Bullet Bill all meet this requirement... So does Pirhana Plant, but I would make Nipper Plant/Muncher a Baby, and Mega Pihrana(Petey Phirana, Dino Phirana, etc.) a Legendary; But it's not my call to make that decision, it's MarioBros'.

[Le Mario Bro]

I wasn't making ShyGuy a starter, just Eevee.

[EpicGyllynn]

I know, MarioBro, that part of my post was devoted to Koopalmier. Also, here is my idea for Pirhana Evolution, but it's your call:
Phirana Plant Family Tree
Nipper Plant/Muncher(Grass)-Baby
Phirana Plant(Grass)-Evolves from Nipper Plant after Trade
Prickly Phirana Plant(Grass, Poison)-Evolves from Phirana Plant at Lv.19
Spikey Phirana Plant(Grass, Poison)-Evoves from Prickly Phirana Plant at Lv.30

Other Phirana Plant Variations
Venus Fire Trap(Grass, Fire)-Evolves from Phirana Plant w/ Fire Flower
Mega Phirana(Grass,*Can have ANY Secondary Type*)-Legendary

Also, I've changed my mind about Starters, I think we need a Fire, Water, and Grass Starter; Because of this, Phirana Plant can be one, but now we need a Water and Fire Type.

[Le Mario Bro]

I like yours better. Quite a lot, actually.

[EpicGyllynn]

Why thank you, MB. I'm really getting into this whole PokeMario thing! Once this is finished, I can make some changes and create a Super Mario Bestiary! I love Long-term Goals! But what do you think would make a good Fire or Water Starter? Oh, and maybe Rex and those Rhino things from SMW could be the Fossil PokeMarios!

[Le Mario Bro]

Okay, here's a confusing one...

Pikmin Family Tree

• Red (Grass, Fire)
  
• Yellow (Grass, Electric)
  
• Blue (Grass, Water)
  
• Purple (Grass, Ground)
  
• White (Grass, Poison)
  

All evolve at Lv. 20 into:

• (Multicolored) Bubulber (Grass)
  

Which then evolves after Trade into:

• (Multicolored) Pianta (Grass, Fighting)
  

Alternate Pikmin Branches

• Bulbmin (Grass, Bug)
  
• Pikmin Swarm (Grass)
  

[EpicGyllynn]

Wait, Pikmin evolving into Piantas? I really wouldn't include Piantas, Toads, or Nokis in this, but, despite how clever it was, I wouldn't make them the evolved form of Pikmin... Well, of that's what you want, though I do like what you have so far!

[Le Mario Bro]

Well, since Pikmin sprouts can go from Leaf to Flower, I can't find it being much of a stretch to go from Flower to Tree.

[EpicGyllynn]

Well, I know that, but Piantas have children... That aren't Pikmin. But what about a Fire/Water Starter? Maybe...
*Gets on Mario Wiki*

[Le Mario Bro]

Hey, all these PokéMarios have kids that aren't their Prevolutions.

'Sides, this whole thing isn't supposed to be serious in the slightest.

[EpicGyllynn]

Well, Nipper Plants and Koopalarva(Koopas that are still partially in their Eggs) really are youmglings of Phirana Plants and Koopa Troopas, but you iz right about dis' not being serious. Stil on my Starter search though! I shall return momentarily!

[EpicGyllynn]

PokeMarioDex 001-006, Design A
001 - Piranha Plant (Grass)

002 - Prickly Piranha Plant (Grass, Poison)

003 - Spiny Piranha Plant (Grass, Poison)

004 - Blargg (Fire)

005 - Magmaw (Fire)

006 - Magmaargh (Fire, Rock)

007 - Bumpty

008 - Cooligan

009 - Penkoon

[EpicGyllynn]

PokeMarioDex 001-009, Design B
001 - Goomba (Normal)
002 - Goombeetle/Astro Goomba (Normal, Steel)
003 - Choomba (Steel, Fire)
004 - Koopa Troopa (Normal)
005 - Terrapin (Fighting, Steel)
006 - Koopatrol (Fighting, Steel)
007 - Piranha Plant (Grass)
008 - Prickly Piranha Plant (Grass)
009 - Spiny Piranha Plant (Grass, Poison)

Bullet Bill Family Tree
Bullet Bill (Steel)


Bombshell Bill (Steel)-Evolves from Bullet Bill at Lv.10


Banzai Bill (Steel)-Evolves from Bombshell Bill at Lv.25


Other Bullet Bill Variations
Evolves after Trade
Missile Bill (Steel)

• Banzai Missile Bill (Steel)-Evolves from Missile Bill at Lv.25
  

Evolves w/ Super Scope
Sniper Bill (Steel)


Evolves w/ Skull Box
Torpedo Ted (Steel, Water)

[Le Mario Bro]

I really like the second Dex format you got there. Just needs a little tweaking.

How about this. What if the text was linked to a picture of the PokéMario in question so that the page doesn't stretch?

I only say because that Bullet Bill is freakin' huge.

[EpicGyllynn]

ThatGuyFromThatPlace believes that Missile Bill would be a more appropriate 1st Evolution for Bullet Bill; He says that because Bombshell Bill and Banzai Bill are NOT heat-seeking(while Missile Bill and Banzai Missile Bill are), and the fact the Black Bill>>Purple Bill>>Giant Purple Bill makes more sense than Black Bill>>Gold Bill>>Giant Black Bill. I do not really think Bombshell Bill is the most apropriate second Evolution, but I certainly don't think Missile Bill is. What do you all think?

[kingkoopa]

Maybe Bullet Bill could be another Eevee like Pokemario where giving it a Mega Mushroom makes it a Banzai Bill which evolves into Missile Banzai Bill. Give it a Metal Cap and it becomes Bombshell Bill. And evolve it normally and it will be a Missile Bill

[Le Mario Bro]

Nov 27, 2010 19:38:59 GMT -5 EpicGyllynn said:

Wait, Pikmin evolving into Piantas? I really wouldn't include Piantas, Toads, or Nokis in this, but, despite how clever it was, I wouldn't make them the evolved form of Pikmin... Well, of that's what you want, though I do like what you have so far!

Okay, I've had a few days to think it over... I'm not really liking the "Pikmin-Evolve-into-Piantas" idea much, either.

Maybe just make the transition from leaf to bud to flower be their evolution?